That is The Marshall Challenge’s new Closing Argument e-newsletter, a weekly deep dive right into a key prison justice difficulty from reporter Jamiles Lartey. Need this delivered to your inbox? Subscribe to future newsletters right here.
A Black man in Massachusetts alleges that police tackled him in a case of mistaken id in 2021, pinning him down with a knee to the neck. In keeping with a lawsuit filed this week, Donovan Johnson cried “I can’t breathe!” however the officer “continued to pin Mr. Johnson to the bottom along with his knee.”
In Houston, one other Black man was fatally shot at the back of the top and neck by an officer investigating an alleged shoplifting incident from a greenback retailer in July. Physique digicam footage launched final week exhibits the person, 47-year-old Roderick Brooks, briefly grabbed the officer’s Taser earlier than the capturing, however let go of it when the officer reached for his gun.
Greater than two years after hundreds of thousands of Individuals took to the streets following the homicide of George Floyd, acquainted tales about police violence persist. By the numbers, 2021 was the deadliest for police shootings since The Washington Put up started monitoring them in 2015. The database Mapping Police Violence discovered related outcomes.
That doesn’t imply nothing has modified. In keeping with a database stored by researchers at Bowling Inexperienced State College, the variety of officers being charged with murder or manslaughter for on-duty killings could beon the rise. Seven officers have been charged in 2017, with a small enhance every year by means of 2021, when a report 21 have been charged. Nevertheless, Professor Philip Stinson, who has been monitoring the information since 2005, cautioned NBC Information that the pattern is just too small to contemplate the change statistically important.
The U.S. Division of Justice has additionally gotten extra engaged in policing departments. On Thursday, 4 present and former Louisville law enforcement officials have been charged with federal crimes associated to the investigation and raid that led to the capturing loss of life of Breonna Taylor in 2020.
On the native degree, many departments have begun experimenting with new approaches, like different response packages that ship unarmed counselors or social staff to sure calls. The Marshall Challenge took a have a look at one such program in Olympia, Washington, which has turn out to be a mannequin for different cities, again in 2020. Different native departments have tried cultural change by the hands of latest charismatic leaders. Our current podcast “Altering the Police,” produced with NPR’s Embedded, walks by means of one case examine on this path of reform — and its limits — within the Yonkers Police Division.
On the state degree, legislatures have handed tons of of police reform legal guidelines because the summer time of 2020. Politico tallied 243 as of Could 2021. One frequent reform goal has been banning or limiting police use of “chokeholds” (though states all outline that time period in another way). In Massachusetts, the place Johnson alleges he was pinned down by an officer’s knee on his neck, that transfer had been explicitly banned two months earlier. It’s unclear what that might imply for the officer accused within the lawsuit if the allegations have been confirmed.
On the federal degree, bipartisan police reform negotiations died in Congress final yr, adopted by a comfort govt order signed by President Joe Biden in Could. That measure changed an ineffectual, and largely forgotten, govt order signed by former President Donald Trump in 2020. The Biden order was, like Trump’s, reflective of the president’s restricted energy over state and native police, and acquired a reasonably tepid response from reform advocates. Most of its key provisions, like boosting reporting to federal misconduct and use of drive databases, are slated to kick in later this yr and thru 2023.
This week, the query of federal policing coverage was reanimated by the announcement of Biden’s “Safer America Plan,” a proposed $37 billion public security funding bundle centered round grants for native departments to rent 100,000 new officers. The trouble seems to be, not less than partly, a messaging technique by Democrats forward of the midterm elections, the place many, particularly in swing districts, really feel weak to Republican assaults round crime.
The bundle was squashed by members of the progressive and Black caucuses — a few of whom have been “furious” about language within the proposal, in accordance with Politico, however it could solely be on pause. “The police funding enhance that Biden needs remains to be possible,” writes Alexander Lekhtman for Filter Journal, “however progressive lawmakers ought to get time to pursue their want for this to be paired with important police accountability measures.”
As written, the plan additionally units out cash incentivizing native governments to fund different response packages, violence interrupter packages, housing and habit therapy. Some have criticized the proposal as “combined messaging.”
One problem for the Biden plan, if it does finally cross, is that many departments say they’re having hassle filling the openings they have already got. That recruiting pool may shrink much more if police departments elevate the minimal age for officers to 25, as one columnist argues they should, citing rising science on age, mind growth and impulsivity.
One technique to open that pool again up: Recruit extra girls. One initiative seeks to have girls make up not less than 30% of police forces by 2030, and NPR seems to be at how a excessive proportion of ladies has affected the tradition of the Madison, Wisconsin, division.
Not everyone seems to be offered on this as an method for fixing issues in policing. “Perhaps they do not yell as a lot, however they nonetheless arrest us,” native activist Brandi Grayson informed NPR. “Perhaps they do not shoot us, however we nonetheless get arrested, we nonetheless get ticketed.”